Polity Atlas
DisputedSource attached · not independently reviewedCLM-1050 · as of 2026-10-30 · about: Political meritocracy (the 'China model' debate) · Author: Polity Atlas editorial team

“Critics such as Andrew Nathan argue that Bell's model describes an ideal rather than China's actual system, in which loyalty and patronage shape promotion and there are no independent checks to verify merit or remove failed leaders.”

Evidence that supports

1

Evidence that contradicts

0

No counter-evidence recorded.

Context

A Discussion of Daniel A. Bell's The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy

Status history

No earlier revisions.

Disputes

No disputes have been filed.

Dispute or add evidence

Submissions are reviewed by an editor and logged publicly on this claim. A source is required.

Your evidence
Not signed in — leave an email so an editor can follow up.