An electoral system is the set of rules used to elect representatives: it helps determine who is elected, how campaigns are fought, the role of political parties and, ultimately, who governs. The main types differ in district size, what voters mark on the ballot and how votes are translated into seats. The descriptions below follow the definitions in the International IDEA Electoral System Design Database.
A comparison of the main types
The table compares the systems by district size, ballot choice and the rule for winning. These features help distinguish systems that may use similar words, such as “majority,” but count votes differently.
| System | District | Voter’s choice | How seats are won |
|---|---|---|---|
| First Past The Post | Single-member | Candidate | The candidate with more votes than any other wins, even without an absolute majority. |
| Block Vote | Multi-member | Usually candidates; voters have as many votes as seats to elect | The candidates with the highest vote totals win. |
| Party Block Vote | Multi-member | One party-centred vote | The party with the most votes wins every seat in the district. |
| Alternative Vote | Single-member | Ranked preferences for candidates | A candidate needs an absolute majority; if no one has one on first preferences, candidates are eliminated and votes reallocated. |
| Two-Round System | Not specified in the definition | Not specified in the definition | A second election is held if the first-round vote does not reach a specified level, most commonly an absolute majority. |
| List Proportional Representation | Multi-member | A party or grouping list; voters vote for a party | Parties receive seats in proportion to their overall share of the vote. |
| Single Transferable Vote | Multi-member | One vote, with preferences | The definition identifies a specified quota of first-preference votes; it does not set out the full counting rule. |
The comparison shows why the name of a system alone is not enough to explain how a ballot works. District size affects how many representatives are elected in an area, while ballot design determines whether a voter selects a candidate, a party or preferences among candidates. The table also separates rules that select individual candidates from the proportional allocation of seats among parties.
Plurality and majority rules
Plurality and majority systems do not all use the same procedure. In First Past The Post, the candidate who has more votes than any other candidate wins, even if that candidate does not have an absolute majority of valid votes. “More than any other” is the key distinction: the rule compares candidates’ totals rather than requiring a candidate to receive more than half of the valid votes.
Block Vote applies a plurality or majority approach in multi-member districts. Voters have as many votes as there are candidates to be elected, and the candidates with the highest totals take the seats. The definition says voters usually choose candidates and, in most systems, may use as many or as few of their votes as they wish. That qualification matters: the ballot arrangements are not described as identical in every instance.
Party Block Vote changes the focus of the ballot from individual candidates to parties. Voters cast one party-centred vote and do not choose among candidates. The party with the most votes takes every seat in the electoral district. This is a distinct rule from proportional allocation, where parties receive seats in proportion to their overall vote share.
Preference voting and additional rounds
The Alternative Vote and the Two-Round System both include a further route to a majority, but they do so differently. In the Alternative Vote, voters rank candidates in a single-member district. If no candidate has an absolute majority of first preferences, the least successful candidates are eliminated and their votes are reallocated according to the next preferences. This continues until a candidate has an absolute majority.
A Two-Round System instead holds a second election when no candidate or party reaches a given vote level in the first round. The source describes an absolute majority as the most common threshold, not the only possible one. It distinguishes two forms: in a majority-plurality form, more than two candidates may contest the second round and the candidate with the highest total wins; in a majority run-off form, only the two leading candidates from the first round compete in the second.
These procedures should not be conflated. The Alternative Vote transfers preferences within a count, whereas a Two-Round System holds another election. Both definitions make the threshold and the treatment of later preferences or votes relevant to understanding the result.
Proportional representation and transferable votes
Under List Proportional Representation, parties or groupings present lists of candidates for multi-member districts. Voters choose a party, and parties receive seats in proportion to their overall share of the vote. In a closed-list system, successful candidates are selected in the order of the list. In an open or free list, voters can influence candidate order by marking individual preferences.
The distinction between closed and open lists is therefore about who can shape the order of candidates who take seats: the list order or voters’ individual preferences. Both forms remain list-based systems in the definition, and both allocate seats to parties in relation to their overall vote share.
The Single Transferable Vote is described as a preferential system in multi-member districts in which each voter has one vote. Its definition refers to candidates surpassing a specified quota of first-preference votes. That is enough to identify the system’s stated features here, but not to describe its complete counting procedure or compare its detailed effects with List PR.
Why the formal rules are only part of the picture
Electoral-system rules are institutional choices, not a guarantee of a particular political result. International IDEA notes that the choice of system can help determine who is elected, how campaigns are conducted, the role of parties and who governs. It also says a system can be designed to encourage cooperation and accommodation in a divided society. These are possible effects of institutional design, not claims that one rule will produce the same outcome everywhere.
In practice, a country’s specific legislation and electoral arrangements matter. A system label does not, by itself, establish every detail of district boundaries, thresholds, ballot instructions or the process for resolving particular cases. For country-level comparisons, consult the relevant country entry in the Electoral System Design Database and check the underlying rules where necessary.
Using electoral-system data carefully
International IDEA’s database provides comparative information on electoral systems used in countries and territories, with country-level data in historical format. Its methodology draws mainly on electoral legislation. Where laws are unavailable, the database may also use information from electoral management bodies, election results, election observation reports and other reputable online materials.
The database says historical data on elections conducted since 1991 were added during 2016–2017. Beginning in 2018, country data are updated following the cycle of parliamentary lower-house elections. Its entries are therefore useful for comparing formal rules over time, but users should pay attention to the date and sources attached to an entry when interpreting a country’s arrangements.
International IDEA also invites researchers and practitioners to submit feedback about missing or incorrect information. The database says submissions are reviewed and entries updated if the proposed information is accurate. This is relevant when a comparison depends on a detailed country rule: the database is a maintained resource, and its own guidance makes room for corrections and additional explanation.
Frequently asked questions
Questions et réponses
Does First Past The Post require a candidate to win more than half the votes?
No. The winning candidate is the one with more votes than any other candidate, even if the candidate does not have an absolute majority of valid votes.
What is the difference between open and closed lists?
With a closed list, successful candidates are taken in list order. With an open or free list, voters can influence the candidate order by marking individual preferences.
Where can I compare electoral-system arrangements by country?
International IDEA’s Electoral System Design Database provides comparative data and country-level information in historical format.
Source : idea.int
À propos de l’auteur
Editorial persona of Polity Atlas.
